A good sales candidate can talk. That’s exactly the problem: the interview format needs to test how they think on a call, not how well they present in one. Situational questions built around a real deal do that better than a resume walkthrough.
Ask about a specific, live scenario
Instead of “tell me about a time you handled objections,” ask the candidate to respond in real time to a specific, realistic objection from a prospect in their target market. The gap between a rehearsed answer and a live one is where you learn how they actually operate on a call.
Watch for structure, not just confidence
Strong AEs and SDRs tend to structure an answer: understand the objection, address the real concern behind it, and confirm next steps. Confident but unstructured answers are a common false positive in sales hiring, and a follow-up question is usually enough to tell the two apart.
Use a two-way interview to standardize the bar
Because sales interviews are naturally conversational, a two-way AI interview that asks a consistent situational prompt and follows up based on the answer gives every candidate the same test, scored the same way, before a human ever gets on the phone.





