Candidate Scoring

Scores you can

check.

check.

check.

Set the criteria for each role, and TailorHire scores every résumé and interview answer against them. Each criterion is rated out of 5 with the evidence behind it, so you see why before you decide.

Set the criteria for each role, and TailorHire scores every résumé and interview answer against them. Each criterion is rated out of 5 with the evidence behind it, so you see why before you decide.

Scorecard · Example

Maya Okafor · Senior Product Manager

Maya Okafor · Senior Product Manager

Maya Okafor · Senior Product Manager

Overall 4.3 / 5

Has shipped onboarding or activation work

Has shipped onboarding or activation work

“We cut setup from nine steps to four.” · Interview 03:18

“We cut setup from nine steps to four.” · Interview 03:18

Must-have

5 / 5

Uses data to make product calls

Uses data to make product calls

Picked the onboarding funnel first and explained why · Assessment

Picked the onboarding funnel first and explained why · Assessment

Must-have

4 / 5

Works well with engineering and design

Works well with engineering and design

Example was light on detail after the follow-up · Interview 06:02

Example was light on detail after the follow-up · Interview 06:02

Baseline

3 / 5

B2B SaaS experience

B2B SaaS experience

Four years as a product manager at Northwind · Résumé

Four years as a product manager at Northwind · Résumé

Nice-to-have

5 / 5

A score is only useful if you can

A score is only useful if you can

A score is only useful if you can

see why.

see why.

see why.

A number on its own asks you to trust it. TailorHire shows the answer behind every criterion, so a hiring manager can agree, disagree or dig in.

A number on its own asks you to trust it. TailorHire shows the answer behind every criterion, so a hiring manager can agree, disagree or dig in.

Criteria in four lanes

Criteria in four lanes

Sort what matters into Must-have, Baseline, Nice-to-have and Red flags. Write your own, or let AI draft them from the role details.

Sort what matters into Must-have, Baseline, Nice-to-have and Red flags. Write your own, or let AI draft them from the role details.

Evidence for every rating

Evidence for every rating

Every criterion is rated out of 5 and points to the answer, résumé line or interview moment behind it. Thin evidence is marked.

Every criterion is rated out of 5 and points to the answer, résumé line or interview moment behind it. Thin evidence is marked.

No guessing on gaps

No guessing on gaps

A criterion that couldn’t be assessed says why. It never counts as zero, and there’s no overall score until every criterion is assessed.

A criterion that couldn’t be assessed says why. It never counts as zero, and there’s no overall score until every criterion is assessed.

Compare side by side

Compare side by side

Everyone in a role is rated on the same criteria, so you can put candidates next to each other, criterion by criterion.

Everyone in a role is rated on the same criteria, so you can put candidates next to each other, criterion by criterion.

How it works

From rubric to

decision.

Scoring follows the criteria you set, and every result can be checked against what the candidate actually said or did.

01

Set the criteria

Add up to eight criteria across Must-have, Baseline, Nice-to-have and Red flags, or let AI draft them from the role.

02

Candidates are screened

Each criterion is checked against what the candidate showed in their resume, assessment and interview.

03

Rated with evidence

Each criterion gets a rating out of 5 with the evidence behind it, plus a note when confidence is low.

04

Your team decides

If a Must-have scores 2 or lower, the candidate is flagged for a person to review. No one is declined automatically.

How it works

From rubric to

decision.

Scoring follows the criteria you set, and every result can be checked against what the candidate actually said or did.

01

Set the criteria

Add up to eight criteria across Must-have, Baseline, Nice-to-have and Red flags, or let AI draft them from the role.

02

Candidates are screened

Each criterion is checked against what the candidate showed in their resume, assessment and interview.

03

Rated with evidence

Each criterion gets a rating out of 5 with the evidence behind it, plus a note when confidence is low.

04

Your team decides

If a Must-have scores 2 or lower, the candidate is flagged for a person to review. No one is declined automatically.

How it works

From rubric to

decision.

Scoring follows the criteria you set, and every result can be checked against what the candidate actually said or did.

01

Set the criteria

Add up to eight criteria across Must-have, Baseline, Nice-to-have and Red flags, or let AI draft them from the role.

02

Candidates are screened

Each criterion is checked against what the candidate showed in their resume, assessment and interview.

03

Rated with evidence

Each criterion gets a rating out of 5 with the evidence behind it, plus a note when confidence is low.

04

Your team decides

If a Must-have scores 2 or lower, the candidate is flagged for a person to review. No one is declined automatically.

No emotion scores

Scores come from what candidates say and do, never from how they look or sound.

Nothing hidden

If you can’t see why a criterion was met, it isn’t on the scorecard.

People make the call

Low Must-have scores are flagged for review. Candidates are never declined automatically.

Candidate scoring: your questions, answered.

What is evidence-based candidate scoring?

You set the criteria for each role, and TailorHire scores every resume and interview answer against them. Each criterion is rated out of 5 and points to the answer, resume line or interview moment behind it, so you see why before you decide.

How do I set the scoring criteria?
What happens when a criterion can’t be assessed?
Does a low score reject a candidate?
Can I compare candidates for the same role?

Find your next

hire.

Bring one open role. We’ll set up the first screens with you.

Find your next

hire.

Bring one open role. We’ll set up the first screens with you.

Find your next

hire.

Bring one open role. We’ll set up the first screens with you.